THE DARK SIDE OF THE PRAIRIE STATE
I’ve lived in Illinois pretty much my whole life, mostly around Chebanse, Kankakee, and Peotone, and if there’s one thing I’ve learned growing up here, it’s that this state has a lot more going on beneath the surface than people give it credit for. Most people think of Chicago first, and sure, that’s part of the story. But once you start paying attention, you realize Illinois is packed with stories, some fascinating, some tragic, and some that just don’t quite make sense.
Take Bachelor’s Grove Cemetery in Midlothian. People call it one of the most haunted places in the country, and I’ll be honest, I used to roll my eyes at stuff like that. Then I took my daughter there for a school project. Every single picture she took had orbs in it. Not one or two… every photo. I still don’t have an explanation for that, and it’s one of those moments that sticks with you whether you want it to or not.
Then you’ve got places like East St. Louis, with its long history of hardship and decline, or Carthage Jail, where Joseph Smith was killed back in 1844. That’s one of those places where history feels a lot heavier when you’re actually standing near it. And Chicago, well, Chicago has its own reputation, especially with spots like the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre site, where organized crime left a mark that still defines part of the city’s identity.
But some of the places that stick with me the most aren’t in the big cities, they’re scattered all over the state.
Cairo is one of them. I’ve been there a few times for work, and it’s honestly hard to describe. It’s like time just stopped, but not in a nostalgic way. It’s something you really have to see to understand, and even then, it leaves you with more questions than answers.
Up north, you’ve got places like Waldheim Cemetery, tied to the Haymarket Riot and a turning point in labor history, and Starved Rock, which is beautiful on the surface but carries the weight of a brutal triple murder from 1960. Even Rockford, which shows up in the headlines more than people would like, has its own history tied to crime and gangs.
And then there are the stories that feel like they shouldn’t even be possible, but happened right here.
Watseka is a perfect example. Back in 1877, a teenage girl named Lurancy Vennum started slipping into these trances, and eventually she claimed she was someone else entirely, a woman who had died years before. She didn’t just act different… she knew things she had no way of knowing. For months, she lived with another family as if she were their daughter returned from the dead. People still debate what really happened, and honestly, I’m not sure anyone will ever fully explain it.
Closer to home for me is Manteno State Hospital. A good friend of mine, God rest his soul, was the security director there, and now my daughter actually lives on that same campus. It definitely has an eerie feel to it when you’re there, knowing its history, but personally, I’ve never seen anything out of the ordinary. Just a lot of stories… and sometimes, that’s enough.
Then there’s the Old Joliet Prison. I’ve driven by it more times than I can count, and back in the mid-70s, I even visited Stateville nearby when Richard Speck was housed there. Places like that remind you that some of Illinois’ darker history isn’t just stories, it’s real, and it’s not that far removed from us.
And some of those stories are just plain unsettling, like what happened in Mattoon in 1944. People reported a shadowy figure creeping through neighborhoods, leaving behind a strange gas that would paralyze them. They called him the “Mad Gasser,” but he was never caught. Some people believe it really happened. Others think it was mass hysteria. Either way, it’s one of those stories that stays with you.
Then there’s Ottawa, where the Radium Girls worked in the 1920s. They were told the paint they used was harmless, encouraged to put it in their mouths, and ended up paying a horrific price. What those women went through helped change workplace safety laws forever, but it came at a cost that’s hard to even imagine.
When you step back and look at all of it, you start to realize Illinois isn’t just a place, it’s a collection of stories. Some are rooted in history, some in tragedy, and some in things we still can’t explain. And if you’ve spent as much time here as I have, you know this is just the beginning.
The more I write about these places, the more I realize we’re barely scratching the surface. Illinois is full of stories that don’t always make it into the history books, the kind you hear in conversations, on back roads, or late at night when people start opening up. Places like Alton have reputations all their own, and stories like Resurrection Mary are just the tip of the iceberg.
So I’ll leave you with this, if you’ve got a story, I want to hear it. Something you’ve seen, something you’ve heard, something you can’t quite explain. Because chances are, the next great Illinois story isn’t out there waiting to be discovered… it’s sitting with someone like you.
